![]()
Last night I finished
Barry Schwartz's
The Paradox of Choice: Why More is Less, the final book in my informal study of positive psychology and the science and economics of happiness. The other books I read were:
And the ones I intend to read later this year on this topic are:
Anyway, I enjoy reading many books in one subject area to really learn a lot from different sources. What's great about this is that each book in the subject area gets easier to read as you become more familiar with the terms specific to that topic. But along with that comes the feeling that every book is kind of the same!
![]()
I'd say that while
The Paradox of Choice does mention research done by
Martin E. P. Seligman (
Authentic Happiness),
Sonja Lyubomirsky (
The How of Happiness) and
Robert H. Frank (
The Economic Naturalist and
Choosing the Right Pond), this book is most like
Daniel Gilbert's
Stumbling on Happiness.
That's because
Stumbling on Happiness and
The Paradox of Choice both focus most on the idea that what people
think makes them happy is not what
actually makes them happy.
I really enjoyed
Stumbling on Happiness, more than
The Paradox of Choice, though I suspect that may simply be because of the order in which I read them; thus
The Paradox of Choice no longer seems fresh or innovative.
I also suspect that the reason I was not overly impressed by
The Paradox of Choice is because this book was published in 2004 and now in 2008, many of the findings in this book are commonly accepted and well known. For example, I've read many articles in the NYTimes in recent years about the idea that fewer choices lead to a boost in happiness though most people believe that more choices equals greater happiness (sometimes called the tyranny of choice):
- January 22, 2004 - "A Nation of Second Guesses" by Barry Schwartz
- December 7, 2004 - "With So Many Choices, No Wonder You Need Help" by Virginia Postrel
- January 26, 2006 - "Is Freedom Just Another Word for Many Things to Buy?" by Barry Schwartz, Hazel Rose Markus and Alana Connor Snibbe
- November 7, 2006 - "Mr. Bland Goes to Washington" by Barry Schwartz
- April 12, 2007 - "Unnatural Selections" by Barry Schwartz
- May 14, 2007 - "Web Videos Let Car Buyers Survey Their Many Choices" by Bob Tedeschi
- July 2, 2007 - "Money for Nothing" by Barry Schwartz
- September 24, 2007 - "TV Remote Moves Over for a Mouse" by David Carr
- February 26, 2008 - "The Advantages of Closing a Few Doors" by John Tierney
- April 17, 2008 - "To Cut or What? The World Butts In" by Anna Jane Grossman
![]()
Okay, well I didn't realize that
Schwartz himself wrote many of these NYTimes pieces...still that definitely explains why the material did not seem fresh to me. I felt the same way when I read
Freakonomics: A Rogue Economist Explores the Hidden Side of Everything by Steven Levitt and Stephen Dubner, when I was consciously aware of having read many of the examples from the book in NYTimes articles by the authors.
Anyway, I don't want to give you the impression that I didn't like
The Paradox of Choice. I did enjoy it, I just didn't find it as exciting as many of the other books I've read lately on positive psychology and the psychology and economics of happiness.
If you're interested in finding out more, click
here to check out this PBS interview with
Schwartz.
And if my comparison to
Stumbling on Happiness has intrigued you, click
here to read the NYTimes review or
here to read an excerpt.